Benedict (Baruch) Spinoza (1632- 1677) |
Table of Contents (Clicking on the links below will take you to that part of this article)
Benedict (Baruch) Spinoza (1632-1677) was the son of a Jewish merchant from Amsterdam. His father and grandfather were originally Spanish crypto-Jews -- that is, Jews who were forced to adopt Christianity in post-Islamic Spain, but secretly remained Jewish. He was educated in traditional Jewish Curriculum. His father died when he was 21, after which he was embroiled in a lawsuit with his stepsister over his father's estate. Spinoza won the suit, but nevertheless handed virtually all of it over to his stepsister. Shortly after, Spinoza's budding theological speculations prompted conflict with Jewish leaders. Spinoza publicly contended that the scriptures do not maintain that God has no body, that angels exist, or that the soul is immortal. After failed attempts to silence him, he was excommunicated in 1656. For a time Spinoza was associated with a former Jesuit who ran a school for children. Spinoza used this as an opportunity to further his own education and to supplement his income by teaching in the school. At this time he also learned the trade of lens grinding for glasses and telescopes.
In his late twenties, he supervised a discussion group on philosophical and
theological issues. As his own ideas developed, he went on retreat from
Amsterdam for three years to formulate them in writing. At a cottage in
Rijnsburg, he wrote A Short Treatise on God, Man and his
Well-Being, and On the Improvement of the Understanding. He also
composed a geometric version of Descartes' Principles of Philosophy, which
friends encouraged him to publish. Part of the purpose of the work was to pave
the way for publishing his own thoughts which were critical of Cartesianism. By
producing such a work, he could not be accused later of not understanding
Descartes. The work appeared in 1663 and was the only writing of Spinoza's
published with his name on it during his life. Further developing his own ideas,
over the next two years Spinoza composed his greatest work, The Ethics.
In 1663 Spinoza left Rijnsburg and moved near The Hague. Hoping to publish the
Ethics, and anticipating controversy, he wrote and published anonymously
his Tractatus Thologico-Politicus (1670) which defends the liberty to
philosophize in the face of religious or political interference. After a self-
initiated and failed diplomatic mission to France, Spinoza and he was forced to
give up hopes of publishing the Ethics. He died in 1677 from a lung
disease, the result of breathing dust from lens grinding.
Spinoza's Pantheism and Method in the Ethics
As directed in Spinoza's Will, the Ethics was published posthumously
along with some of his other works (1677). The Ethics is about 200 pages
in length and in five parts:
In Part One of the Ethics, "Concerning God," after presenting a short
list of definitions and axioms, Spinoza deduces 36 propositions which explain
the nature of God. The most important of these is Proposition 14, which
expresses Spinoza's pantheism: "Besides God, no substance can be granted or
conceived." The term "pantheism" (literally all-God) means that God is identical
to the universe as a whole. For example my car, my house, and even I myself are
all parts of God. Other Western philosophers before Spinoza advocated pantheism,
including Xenophanes, Parmenides, Plotinus, and Meister Eckhardt. However, the
vast majority of Western philosophers and theologians strongly rejected this
view in favor of a transcendent concept of God which holds that God is distinct
from his creation. Indeed, some theologians maintained that God has the
attribute of separateness thus being completely separate from the rest of the
universe, including the physical world and humans. Spinoza's argument for
pantheism in Proposition 14 is as follows:
As noted, Spinoza opens part one of the Ethics with a list of
definitions and axioms. His list of definitions are as follows:
Like definitions, axioms are also foundational elements from which
propositions are derived. Rather than defining key terms, though, Spinoza's
axioms stipulate some foundational fact about the world.
Its most
visibly distinguishing feature is its style of composition modeled after
Euclid's geometry. Each of the five parts opens with a brief list of definitions
and axioms, and from these a series of propositions (or theorems) are deduced.
Spinoza initially composed the first parts of the Ethics in dialog form,
but rejected this for the more precise -- and unfortunately more difficult --
geometric method. In general, geometric proofs are designed so that if we accept
the definitions and axioms at the outset, and deductions from these are properly
made, then we must accept the concluded propositions. However, as Leibniz
observed, even though Spinoza's system follows this style, it nevertheless lacks
mathematical rigor. Consequently, we must look at the content of Spinoza's
complete system and accept or reject it on its own merits, rather than from the
success of the various deductions.
Proposition 5. There cannot exist in the universe two or more
substances having the same nature or attribute.
The intuition behind Spinoza's argument above can be expressed
simply. Two separate substances cannot share the same attributes (P 5). God has
every actual and possible attribute (P 11). Thus, no other substance can exist.
To illustrate Spinoza's point, imagine an infinitely long list of qualities such
as "consiousness" and "three-dimensionality." For Spinoza, each attribute on
this list can be assigned to only one substance or thing. So, substance 1 might
exclusively have the attribute of "consciousness," and substance 2 might
exclusively have the attribute of "three- dimensionality." However, God has
already been assigned all attributes on the list, and no attributes are left to
assign to other substances. Since a substance can't exist if it doesn't have any
attributes, then God is the only substance which exists.
Proposition 11: God
(defined as a substance consisting of infinite attributes, of which each
expresses eternal and infinite essentiality) necessarily exists.
Therefore,
Proposition 14: Besides God, no substance can be granted or conceived.
Initially, the most important of the definitions below are those
of substance, attribute, and mode. Substance, for Spinoza, turns out to be the
totality of the universe. An attribute is an all- encompassing property of the
universe, such as being three dimensional. Spinoza commentators give various
explanations of "attribute" and its relation to "substance." Jonathan Bennett
notes that that "An attribute for Spinoza is a basic way of being -- a property
which sprawls across everything... [that pertains to that substance]." Edwin
Curley notes that for Spinoza the totality of a thing's attributes constitutes
its substance. A mode (or modification) is a more confined property of the
universe, or how an attribute appears on a smaller level. For example, the shape
of a tree is a modification of the universe's larger attribute
"three-dimensionality."